Windows 11 design chief rebuts critics over missing Windows 10 feature, concedes MS’s choices are “far from” perfect

MS’s Vice President of Design for Windows, Diego Baca, says a taskbar lock switch like the one in Windows 10 would not solve the challenge of dragging the Windows 11 taskbar. It would add an extra step and could interfere with rearranging taskbar icons or system tray items. He also rejected reports claiming that drag-to-move is never returning to Windows 11, stating, “Nothing is beyond reconsideration.”

Windows 11 has finally added the ability to place the taskbar on any edge of the screen, but only through Settings. Many users, including me, suggested restoring Windows 10’s “Lock the taskbar” option to prevent accidental dragging. However, Baca’s response explains why MS does not consider the solution that simple.

MS Says a Lock for the Windows 11 Taskbar Would Create New Problems

“For those suggesting an ‘auto-lock’ or lock/unlock setting as a magic solution, it really isn’t that simple,” Baca wrote on X. “You’re introducing additional friction to solve a relatively infrequent task. Now, every time you want to move the taskbar, you first need to unlock it.”

He also explained that, “depending on how locking is implemented, you risk interfering with more common interactions, like rearranging icons or moving items in the system tray.”

Windows 11 does not have a “Lock the taskbar” option because its taskbar was rebuilt from scratch and did not retain the old code. A lock would therefore need to be developed from the ground up, and MS would have to determine exactly what it restricts. If it locked only the taskbar’s position, users would still need to unlock it before every move. If it locked additional elements, it could interfere with dragging pinned apps, which most users do far more often than moving the taskbar.

According to Baca, the decision was informed by Windows 10, “where we saw a significant volume of accidental taskbar movements.” MS has not shared specific figures.

In our earlier report, I argued that drag-to-move could return with the taskbar locked by default. The trade-off is now clearer.

MS Says Nobody Said “Never” About Drag-to-Move

“First, let’s get the facts straight. No one said ‘never,’” Baca wrote. He added that MS continuously evaluates “feedback from telemetry, Feedback Hub, social channels, and other sources, weighing it against our design and product priorities.”

“Please don’t turn an explanation of a design decision into a declaration that something will ‘NEVER’ happen. That’s simply not what I said,” he added.

In his May Windows Insider blog post, Baca said MS is “evaluating additional features like different taskbar positions per monitor and drag and drop.” When MS first announced the movable taskbar, it had also been testing a right-click menu with Left, Top, Right, and Bottom buttons. We found that the remaining code still exists, which, in my opinion, is a better approach if dragging the taskbar is not being considered.

History also supports his position. In 2022, MS said the movable taskbar was not returning anytime soon, but it came back in 2026. In 2021, MS said that “dragging a file onto an app in the taskbar to open it in that app is not supported in Windows 11,” but the feature returned with the Windows 11 2022 Update. The Never combine taskbar buttons option also made a comeback.

To be clear, MS has not promised drag-to-move or provided a timeline.

Windows 11’s Taskbar Serves Over a Billion People, and Every Change Has Trade-Offs

“Windows is a complex system used by over a billion people in countless different ways,” Baca said. “Every decision introduces trade-offs, dependencies, and permutations that we need to consider.”

In another response, he listed “user research, implementation details, technical constraints, accessibility, consistency” among the relevant factors and said, “Not everyone has visibility into the full picture.” He also rejected the claim that the setting is hidden, arguing that a single right-click “is hardly buried.”

Baca also said he is “100% supportive of third-party software that extends Windows.” For users who frequently move their taskbar and are not concerned about accidental dragging, he described third-party drag tools as “perfect.”

Credit where it is due: it is rare to see a MS vice president publicly explain a design decision in such detail and then acknowledge, “That doesn’t mean every decision we make is perfect or beyond criticism. Far from it!” I appreciate MS being more transparent about its decisions.

“There’s always room for improvement, and we are always listening, learning, and acting on feedback,” Baca said. Drag-to-move is not currently on the way, but the door remains open.

Would you accept an unlocking step if it meant restoring drag-to-move? Let us know in the comments.

Windows Latest depends on readers like you. Make us your Preferred Source on Google Discover and Google Search, and help our independent reporting reach more people.